About | FAQ | Contact | Advertise  | RSS Feed
Subscribe to this feed
ADVANCE for Physician Assistants RSS Feed
Search
Login | Sign Up

Current Issue

Subscriptions are FREE to Qualified Physician Assistants


Features

Just Say No


View Comments (4)Print ArticleEmail Article

Editor's note: This opinion piece was originally written for our sister publication, ADVANCE for Nurse Practitioners. We're adding it to our site because it also applies to physician assistants. Please feel free to share your thoughts on this piece in the comment section below.

Although most health care providers would firmly deny that they are influenced by pharmaceutical marketing, evidence to the contrary is mounting. The truth is that pharmaceutical marketing--the three "F's" of flattery, food and freebies--are powerful tools that adversely influence our patient care decisions.

What's the Harm?
Pharmaceutical marketing increases the number and cost of prescriptions. So while the drug companies pay for dinner, our expenses are passed on to patients and third-party payers and, ultimately, increase health care costs for all of us. Patients become two-time losers: They pay more for drugs, and they also pay for the marketing freebies.

Say No
My own professional journey away from drug marketing took years. The lunches and free "educational" events are hard to give up. Like many NPs, I was uncomfortable with the three F's, but I viewed them as part of normal professional practice. I liked dinner at a nice restaurant. I was also naive enough to think that the programs were all educational. And my patients were grateful for free samples--until they filled the prescription!

It is not easy to say no. A physician colleague observed that participation in marketing is like an addiction, and this analogy has been used for years. The Web site www.perxinfo.org has helpful information and a series of educational modules about evaluating drug information.

You've Got a Problem When ...
Based on my observations, you may want to reconsider your pharma perceptions if the following apply to you:

You use large bags to collect goodies at meetings. Conference exhibit halls are often the site of unusual freebie frenzy. NPs often carry large tote bags to cart all the pens, papers, candies and other items given away at the booths. At one meeting, I was surprised to find several NPs carting around suitcases for freebies.

You attend a meeting because you will get food. I know of one professional group whose industry-sponsored dinners were attended by NPs who left after the meals. Ask yourself, would I attend this meeting if there were no food? If yes, you can attend the meeting and refuse the food.

You see a drug representative only to get something. Sampling is a good example of using a drug rep to get something. The truth is that you get the samples, but the samples get you and your patient. The sale of prescription drugs increases significantly when they are sampled. The strategy for increasing sales is not hard to follow. Prescribers are taught to use the drug because they are handing the drug out to their patients. In many cases, time matters, and if prescribers have quick information at hand, the drug soon becomes one of their main arsenal agents. Samples also have a positive effect on patients, but the benefit may be short lived. Often the recipient is treated with a more expensive alternative to generic drugs.

Recent guideline changes from the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America are limiting noneducational materials to health care providers. (Read the guidelines at www.phrma.org.) The new guidelines may limit freebies, but they have not curtailed the food and activities. Still, it is a change in the right direction.

Nancy Crigger is a family nurse practitioner and nurse ethicist who has a PhD in nursing and a master's degree in philosophy. She is an associate professor at William Jewell College in Liberty, Mo.


 

Keep the NP opinion pieces to the NP publications. It's obvious from the responses (which I agree with) that NPs and PAs don't share these similar views

mark October 17, 2009



I never cease being amazed by the self-rightousness of the anti big pharma academians. Personally, I love going to the dinners, both for the food and the comraderie and well....the stuff! I use a great laser pointer from Tygacil to play with my cat, he certainly appreciates it! As was well stated by another post, if you are so insecure in your therapies that a drug-rep dinner would change the way you practice, well you have bigger problems to attend to. And has there been any evidence that drug prices have come down since they stopped giving away the shwag?
Personally I can tell you one thing for sure. In the ER we have a perpetual shortage of trauma shears!! We used to have a steady supply of them from drug reps and I assure you I never gave a moments thought to what drug was labeled on the trauma shears.
Maybe I should have been telling pt's all these years that I was cutting off their clothes with scissors from the fine people at Phizer! "This expeditious removal of your garments brought to you by Lovenox!" LOL

Rob Booth,  EMPA-C,  Methodist Hosp.October 10, 2009
Memphis, TN



The "addiction" cited in this article suggests that the author may need a 12 step program. I am amazed at the readiness to condem the relationship between those of us in the trenches and big pharma. Meanwhile, those in research continue to fund their existence via big pharma. If the advice I get at a dinner meeting is tainted, then its source, pharma sponsored research, is tainted also. The same goes for every relationship between business and healthcare, including advertising in journals. By the way, do you actually read the ads? Do not go to the hospital book fair, the local professional society internet symposium or anything that is sponsored. Hospitals do intensive marketing to control our referral patterns and professional societies want our dues and PAC dollars to lobby law makers. I, for one, am neither addicted or so insecure in my rational thought processes as to be taken in by the big pharma marketing plan. Just because that is their intention does not make it mine. I do not go "for the meal." I go for the opportunity to converse with fellow professionals about how we treat disease. Take personal responsibility for comparing what they tell you and what competiong interests say.

Scott October 10, 2009



Read all comments (4) >>


     

Email: *

Email, first name, comment and security code are required fields; all other fields are optional. With the exception of email, any information you provide will be displayed with your comment.

First * Last
Name:
Title Field Facility
Work:
City State
Location:

Comments: *
To prevent comment spam, please type the code you see below into the code field before submitting your comment. If you cannot read the numbers in the below image, reload the page to generate a new one.

Captcha
Enter the security code below: *

Fields marked with an * are required.

 

Search Jobs

Zip

Go